Fire risk assessor prosecuted for inadequate risk assessment

David Thompson of Toftwood Health & Safety Solutions was fined £750 and ordered to pay a £170 surcharge and £1,000 costs in August 2019 for failing to provide a suitable and sufficient fire risk assessment.

Thompson pleaded guilty to the offence under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005. The offence related to a risk assessment carried out at Hexagon student accommodation on Rockingham Lane, Sheffield. Ashgate Property Developments Ltd had already been fined £36,000 at an earlier hearing for three separate offences relating to the same premises.

In summing up this case, the judge said that “competence is knowing when you yourself aren’t able to do something – and that Risk Assessors should recognise the limits of their experience and expertise.”

Area manager Steve Helps, said, “This verdict should serve as a stark warning to building owners that people carrying out fire risk assessments should be competent and able to properly consider all of the risks within buildings, particular where people’s lives could be placed at risk. The sentence in this case proves that people will rightly be held to account if risk assessments are found to be insufficient.”

Assurity Consulting are leading experts in workplace health, safety and environmental compliance. Our team of fire safety experts are Associate members of the Institute of Fire Engineers, and have vast experience in a range of environments, offering the best independent advice on fire safety management. For more information on our range of services, please contact us on tel. +44 (0)1403 269375 or email us